Cases of serious liver injury associated with the use of green tea extract-containing natural health products continue to be reported worldwide. However, they are rare and unpredictable (idiosyncratic) events.
Products affected
Numerous natural health products contain green tea extract (
Camellia sinensis extract) as a medicinal ingredient. Green tea is a naturally occurring source of antioxidants, such as epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG) and other catechins, and all natural health products include recommended dosages on the labels.
According to Health Canada’s
Licensed Natural Health Products Database there are currently over 2,500 products licensed in Canada containing green tea extract as a medicinal ingredient, of which over 550 are licensed with health claims referencing weight management (in combination with diet and exercise). Green tea extract-containing natural health products are also used in Canada as a source of antioxidants for the maintenance of good health.
Green tea in any form, including as an extract, is considered generally safe for the vast majority of consumers.
Background information
Green tea extract can be present in natural health products as a single ingredient or in combination with other medicinal ingredients for various uses, including to help in weight management and as a source of antioxidants for the maintenance of good health. These natural health products are available in Canada in various oral dosage forms such as capsules, tablets, powders and liquids. Health Canada’s
Green Tea Extracts monograph, which serves as a licensing standard for natural health products containing green tea extract as a medicinal ingredient, includes risk statements advising consumers to take these products with food and to consult a healthcare professional prior to use if they have a liver disorder or if they develop signs or symptoms of liver damage.
Because of ongoing reporting of serious cases of liver injury worldwide, Health Canada conducted an assessment to examine the current data on the potential risk of liver injury with green tea extract-containing natural health products, and to determine if the current mitigation measures are sufficient. Health Canada published a summary of a recent domestic case of serious liver injury in the
Health Product InfoWatch in October 2016, to increase awareness among healthcare professionals.
Between 2006 and 2016, 11 serious Canadian cases of liver injury associated with green tea extract-containing natural health products had been reported to Health Canada. Of these 11 cases, only 2 had enough information to be further assessed. In the most recent case published in a 2016
Health Product InfoWatch, it was determined that this case of hepatotoxicity (liver injury) had a “probable” causal association, while the second case, reported in 2006, had a “possible” relation to the use of green tea extract-containing natural health products. These cases were each reported with different green tea extract-containing natural health products. A search in the
World Health Organization Adverse Drug Reaction Database found 89 global reports of liver injury associated with the use of green tea-containing products; however, due to limitations in the available information, no further causality assessment could be conducted by Health Canada.
Health Canada’s review concluded that, as previously determined, there may be a link between consumption of green tea extract-containing natural health products and the risk of rare and unpredictable (idiosyncratic) cases of liver injury. As with other cases of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury, no dose-response relationship could be established, and this injury may be due to an interaction of factors, including genetic, host and environmental factors. The Health Canada Green Tea Extracts monograph, published in 2008, includes risk statements for consumers to:
-
consult a healthcare practitioner prior to use of these products if they have a liver disorder or if they develop symptoms of liver trouble (such as abdominal pain, dark urine or jaundice), and
-
take the product with food.
This safety information is also required to be included on the product label for green tea extract-containing natural health products. Although the safety information had already been required, Health Canada’s review found that cases of liver injury continue to be reported in Canada and worldwide, and that Canadian labelling could be stronger. Therefore, Health Canada is requiring strengthening of the labelled safety information for impacted green tea extract-containing natural health products. The revised risk statements will advise consumers:
-
to stop the use of green tea extract-containing natural health products if they develop symptoms of liver trouble (i.e., yellowing of the skin/eyes [jaundice], dark urine, sweating, nausea, stomach pain, unusual tiredness, and /or loss of appetite), and consult a healthcare practitioner; and
-
that rare cases of unpredictable liver injury have been reported internationally and in Canada.
The safety review also recommended that green tea extract-containing products be used by adults only. While the 2008
Green Tea Extracts monograph did not specify the age limit, the monograph was
updated in August 2017 to include a subpopulation “adults (18 years and older)”.
As a precautionary measure, Health Canada is requesting product licence holders of natural health products containing green tea extract as a medicinal ingredient and are intended for children and adolescents, to either remove the green tea extract from the product, or revise the label to indicate that the product is for adults (18 years and older) only.